Water Cooler Games - Tabloid Games

Tabloid Games
June 5, 2007 - by Ian Bogost

The Game Show Network has released a few newsgames, which we've discussed before here (1, 2, 3). Their latest, The Prison Life: Paris, came out yesterday, in time with the start of Paris Hilton's 45 day jail sentence. The gameplay involves helping Paris press vanity license plates.

Over at Gameology, Zach Whalen makes a compelling argument about these games. He calls them Tabloid Games, suggesting that the GSN games are actually trying to do something different from, say, September 12 or the recent newsgames I've been working on. Quoth Zach:

Not only do most of these GSN games rely on celebrities and sex, but like tabloid news, they also revolve around a hook or punchline and are more concerned with framing a reaction to something having happened rather than reporting what actually did happen. ... So even though these games aren't all individually impressive or interesting, I think if we take them as the same kind of rhetoric that tabloid journalism produces, we can agree that they are generally rhetorically effective.

I find this line of thinking convincing, although I'd argue that the examples of good newsgames we have seen thusfar editorialize more than they report. I'm sure there are many more tabloid games out there on the web, probably more than their are newsgames of the editorial sort. That in mind, here's a question: is something like the Zidane Head Butt Game more a newsgame or more a tabloid game?

Comments (1) | Post a Comment | TrackBack (0)

Comment from michaelArteaga on June 6, 2007

In general I would say that the definition is up to the entity which takes on the game.

My gut tells me that I would see the Zidane H.B. Game on a site that considers itself a ''tabloid'' before I would see it offered on a site considering itself to be more ''news'' oriented.

But then again, I say to myself, news entities often have sections on sports. And is something like ESPN a source of news? I would think many would answer, 'yes.'

I'm not really among that many, but if more say 'yae' than 'nae,' well, let's make it democratic.

Anyway, I see the Zidane H.B. Game as a more comical section of sports news. Combining comedy and sports into something new: Corts (do I get credit for that word?)

POST A COMMENT

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

TRACKBACKS

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.watercoolergames.org/mt-tback.cgi/797

Links to weblogs that reference Tabloid Games will be listed here.